Taylor Swift and Blake Lively’s text messages will have to be given to Justin Baldoni in the "It Ends With Us" lawsuit, a judge has ruled.

A judge has denied Blake Lively's motion for a protective order to keep her communications with Taylor Swift regarding It Ends With Us out of Justin Baldoni's hands. In new documents obtained by PEOPLE,

Despite the earnest efforts of Blake Lively's lawyers, the private correspondence between the Another Simple Favor star and superstar buddy Taylor Swift over what was going on during the rocky production of It Ends With Us and the subsequent legal battles with co-star Justin Baldoni are not going to stay as private as the actress